You know, with all the ranting and raving that runs the airways these days, the predictably controversial talking heads of radio along with their shouting and outright rude counterparts on television “news” (and I do use the word lightly) programs, one would think we have become a nation of adamant nonsense. What I hear sounds more like the Red Queen in Alice in Wonderland and less like the lofty ideals imagined by our Forefathers (and Mothers) . The Red Queen ordered shrilly, for any provocation or for none at all, the command “Off with their heads!”… before finding out whose head or why. It was and is a little scary. 

So please let us not confuse our diverse nation with its 50 states and about 310 million individuals and their variant needs and goals with the so-called Patriots, continuing to foam at the mouth, who either:

A. Stir up the pot using self aggrandizing slander of anyone or anything that SEEMS to oppose their fanatically held sound bite views, with the nuance, subtlety, and thoughtfulness of a brick through a plate-glass window. I will not mention any of these personalities by name as I do not want to give them any more free press than they already get.

 B. This group is similar to those of the above, except for instead of making millions by being media pushers, they are politicians.  Sure, money and fame are two of their goals, but their drug of choice is power and staying in it, no matter the cost or without care to their constituency, that has  them shouting, “Foul!” to any idea that “appears” to come from the other side of the aisle.  I say “appears”, because as the non-contrarian media continues to do its job, we find many of these ideas were first proposed by them!! 

C.  Which leads us to the last, and most unfortunate of all of the screaming mimis, more than a few (although not all)  Tea Party members.  When our Boston revolutionaries threw that tea into the harbor, they too were as mad as hell and weren’t going to take it anymore.  Luckily for them, they didn’t have groups A and B using them as pawns and puppets for their own selfish ends.  Many of the members of the Tea Party have legitimate concerns and articulate them, if not convincingly, at least soundly. 

But too many have joined a movement, fiery and passionate, that perhaps gives them a sense of purpose and connection, but it is more like a “loud gong signifying nothing.”  They are being used by those feeding them alarming bits of information WITHOUT CONTEXT. The somewhat sly and charismatic rabble rousers, rich and powerful, know that it is Fear and not Fact that motivates a mob.  

Mark Twain cleverly defined a Patriot as “The person who can holler the loudest without knowing what he is hollering about.” How true, wise words from our favorite American humorist. Let’s heed them.  Except for the unavoidable and universal childhood stage that we all must go through and that hopefully passes with age (not dubbed “the terrible twos” for nothing), NO should be something more than a knee jerk reaction to any new idea. Might it be more patriotic, never mind more helpful, to learn to curb our childish impulses to respond to anything, reasonable or not, with NO? 

We may very well be a nation of natural-born contrarians. I love that we can argue about things that matter, in private and in public.  It’s sometimes fun to argue just for argument’s sake to pass the time with friends and family. (Although it’s annoying to be with those who seem to take the opposite opinion in every discussion).  Just the same, we are blessedly free.  With that comes the responsibility to think, to openly weigh both sides of an argument, to be willing to change our opinions. 

So, let’s go to our tea parties and leave the mad hatters with Alice; they may be exciting but they are too damn exhausting.



  1. Hullo Catherine,
    Being an avid follower of US politics, I am very much aware of the Tea Party movement, and sadly, I agree with all that you say. In a famous English comedy series called ‘Yes Minister’, the Permanent Cabinet Secretary (No.1 Civil Servant of the British Government) advised the Prime Minister that it is always best to put the difficult bit on the title of a government policy paper. By labelling it “Health”, “Security” or “Unemployment”, you immediately give the impression that something has in fact already been done to address the issue. You stake your obstinate claim on the header, as in this case, “Patriots”, and by the simply virtue of naming yourself thus, anyone who is against the contents of your dogma is immediately labeled as ‘unAmerican unpatriotic Liberal Pinko Socialist’. Actual assessment of the substantive issues are in fact …….., an anyone who is brave in enough to question the legitimacy of your political stand is accused as being part of the soft leftwing inteligentsia.
    Similarly, we find that in my faith, the labelling of something as ‘Islamic’ immediately puts a gloss of spiritual authority, when in fact, a mild prodding of the basic tenets of the Islamic-Whatever would establish intentions and means not wholly charitable, honest or tolerant. Often the root cause of this unconscionable is in fear, insecurity and a thorough vacuum of historical knowledge and precedence. I was hot under the coller about this and wrote…

    65. The Great Islamic Pail
    Islamic courses and Islamic rules,
    Islamic books and Islamic schools,
    Islamic shops and Islamic banks,
    Islamic bombs and Islamic tanks.
    This is what my Islam is made of.

    Islamic shoes and Islamic sandals,
    Islamic tales and Islamic fables,
    Islamic labels and Islamic rebels,
    Islamic banging on Islamic tables.
    This is what my Islam is made of.

    Islamic banner and Islamic country,
    Islamic state and Islamic party,
    Islamic bread with Islamic buns,
    Islamic hate with Islamic guns.
    This is what my Islam is made of.

    O’ Lord, we are spreading the word of “Islam”,
    We have succeeded where the caliphs have failed,
    All and sundry we have labeled “Islam”,
    So what was once the humble bucket,
    Is now the Great Islamic Pail.

    Racism and intolerance is everywhere. Extremism becomes a favourite weapon of the populist politician. It is a favoured tool because, alas, mankind is easily provoked to alienate another segment of humanity and treat these ‘others’ as ‘the Enemy’. History has shown this, time and time again.

    There is no real enemy. And as far as I am aware, we still live on the same planet and the same Sun and Moon shines over our petty quarrels and vindictiveness. God unites, but often is is Man who divides.

    Naughty. Naughty.

    • Taufiq, I wish that your poem about some of your frustrations with Islam could be published in every one of our blogs, newspapers, and read on CNN. People need to be reminded that it’s the moderates that make up the majority of our planet, moderate in their speech, thought, and beliefs. WE ARE ALL IN THIS TOGETHER, no matter how much fear and ignorance and hate would pull the wool over our eyes and make us see only our separateness. Extra suffering all around; what stupidity! Blessings, Katherine

  2. Hehehe. Well the poem is posted on my blog at least. I think we should gather up extremists of all faith and ideologies and put ’em on a deserted island and give them boxing gloves.

    Then the rest of us can get on with living and getting along.

    May Mercy grace your thoughts.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s